5.0 on Google · Trusted by 1,500+ Brands · Custom Clothing Manufacturer · Made in the USA
USA manufacturing, nationwide fulfillment and one account team, run out of a single Jacksonville facility.
Tell us your product, quantity and timeline. Custom quote back within 24 hours.
Screen printing costs more upfront but drops fast at volume; digital printing has no setup fees but holds a higher per-unit floor. The crossover point where screen printing becomes cheaper typically falls between 24 and 48 units, depending on color count and artwork complexity. Get the method wrong for your quantity and you’ll either overpay on setup for a small run or leave significant savings on the table at scale.
Screen printing wins at volume with simple artwork. Digital printing wins at low quantities and for complex, photo-quality designs. This breakdown gives you the cost structure behind both methods, the hidden fees that skew comparisons, and a clear decision framework to match the right method to your order.
Most buyers compare quotes at face value by looking at the total at the bottom of the invoice. The problem is that screen print quotes bundle setup into the per-unit price at low quantities, while digital print quotes often hide substrate upcharges. You end up comparing numbers that aren’t built the same way.
Order quantity is the variable that flips which method is cheaper. A buyer who orders 24 shirts on a screen print contract might see a high per-unit price and assume screen printing is always expensive. It isn’t. The setup cost is simply getting amortized across too few units. At 144 units, that same job often looks completely different on a cost-per-shirt basis.
Every color in a screen print design requires a separate screen to be made, exposed, and mounted on press. Industry pricing for screen setup typically runs $25–$75 per screen per color. A three-color front logo means three screens before a single shirt gets printed. That cost sits on top of your per-unit price and gets paid regardless of how many shirts you order.
Once the screens are made, screen printing scales efficiently. The actual press run is fast, ink consumption per shirt is low, and the labor cost per unit drops as quantity climbs. Per-unit prices can fall from a few dollars per print at 50 units to under a dollar per print at 500 units for a simple design.
Repeat orders lower costs further if the shop stores your screens between runs. Some decorators charge a screen storage fee (typically a few dollars per screen per month); others build it into a program price. If you’re running the same seasonal logo every quarter, stored screens eliminate re-setup costs entirely.
Full-coverage prints, oversized designs, and specialty inks like metallics or puff carry surcharges. These reflect real material and press time differences, not arbitrary fees. Always ask what the base print size is and what triggers an oversize upcharge on any quote.
You can explore how screen printing production in Jacksonville handles multi-color and specialty ink jobs if you’re sourcing domestic production for a brand program.
Digital printing (DTG and DTF) charges a per-print rate with no screen setup cost. The artwork goes directly from a file to the printer. This makes digital the clear winner for low quantities where screen setup fees would dominate the total. For a 12-shirt run, skipping three screens at $50 each means $150 stays in your budget before you even look at the per-shirt print rate.
Digital printing handles unlimited colors, gradients, and photographic images without any price penalty for color count. A 16-color gradient design costs the same to print digitally as a two-color flat logo. Submit files at 300 DPI minimum in PNG or PDF format to avoid potential art preparation fees.
DTG printing works best on 100% cotton or high-cotton blends. Polyester-heavy fabrics require a pretreatment step that adds cost and can affect hand feel if not done correctly. DTF transfers sidestep the substrate sensitivity issue and apply to a wider fabric range, but the transfer material adds its own cost layer.
MFG Merch runs DTG printing in Jacksonville on the actual garment before bulk commitment, which confirms ink adhesion and wash performance for the specific fabric in your program.
The quantity where screen printing becomes cheaper than digital depends on two variables: color count and design complexity. For a simple one- or two-color design, screen printing typically beats digital somewhere between 24 and 48 units once setup fees are distributed across the run. For a five-color design, the crossover shifts higher because the setup fee is larger.
| Run Size | 1–2 Color Design | 4–6 Color Design | Photographic or Gradient |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 24 units | Digital wins | Digital wins | Digital wins |
| 24–48 units | Screen often wins | Digital often wins | Digital wins |
| 48–100 units | Screen wins clearly | Screen approaching parity | Digital still competitive |
| 100+ units | Screen wins decisively | Screen wins | Screen or digital (quality target) |
If you plan to reorder, ask explicitly whether the shop stores screens and what they charge per screen per month. For a brand running quarterly programs, stored screens save meaningful setup costs over a year.
Standard screen printing uses mixed inks that approximate your brand color. An exact Pantone match requires a custom ink mix, which usually carries an upcharge per color. Digital printing renders color through a CMYK process, so PMS matching here is an approximation.
Screen printing rush fees often apply to the setup phase, keeping the premium fixed regardless of quantity. Digital rush fees apply to the print queue and may scale with units.
Factor spoilage into any screen print budget at roughly 2–3% of the run for a new design. Digital spoilage rates tend to be lower for short runs because there is no press registration to dial in.
If you’re running a repeat brand program and want setup costs locked in across multiple drops, MFG Merch handles silk screen printing programs in Jacksonville with stored screens and program pricing for consistent reorders.
Screen printing is the right call for bulk runs of 48 units or more with simple spot-color artwork. The setup cost amortizes across the run, and the per-unit price drops sharply at 100, 144, and 288 units. For any run of 100 or more units with a logo under four colors, screen printing beats digital every time.
Digital is the right method for short runs under 24 units, photographic or gradient-heavy artwork, and designs that change between individual units. A 12-piece team kit with individual names is a job screen printing simply can’t compete with on price. Just skip DTG on high-polyester performance fabrics without a confirmed pretreatment test, or you’ll see cracking within 10–15 wash cycles.
A quote that shows only a per-unit price without itemizing setup, art, and finishing is incomplete. Before you sign off, ask for the setup fee per color, the art preparation fee, the oversize print surcharge threshold, and whether spoilage is covered. These line items can shift the total by 15–25% on a small run.
Committing to the wrong print method before confirming the cost structure is one of the fastest ways to overspend on a launch run. The screen vs. digital price gap is real, and it moves in opposite directions depending on where your order falls relative to the crossover range.
MFG Merch handles both screen printing and digital decoration in-house, so our recommendation is based on your quantity and artwork, not on which press has open capacity. Decoration samples on the actual garment are available before bulk commitment.
Send a quantity range, your in-hand date, your artwork file, and the garment or fabric type you have in mind to MFG Merch and we’ll confirm which method fits your budget and timeline before you commit to a run.
For a one- or two-color design, screen printing usually becomes cheaper somewhere between 24 and 48 units once setup fees are spread across the run. For designs with four or more colors, the crossover point shifts higher because each additional color adds another screen fee.
Yes, because each color requires a separate screen and setup fee. A six-color design can add $150–$450 in setup charges. Digital printing has no color penalty, so complex or multicolor artwork costs the same per unit regardless of color count.
Digital print pricing is more standardized because there is no setup variable to negotiate. Screen print quotes have more room to move on setup fees for large programs or long-term repeat orders. Always ask about program rates if you’re placing monthly or quarterly digital runs.
Yes, and this is often the smartest approach for a new design. Run 12–24 units digitally to confirm fit and quality, then switch to screen printing for the bulk run. Most artwork translates between methods without major changes.
DTF works on a wider range of fabrics including polyester without pretreatment, which removes a key cost and compatibility issue of DTG. Per-unit costs for DTF are comparable to DTG at low quantities, but DTF may carry a minimum transfer sheet size that makes very small designs slightly less efficient.
TLDR: For shorts and joggers, prioritizing breathability, comfort, and durability is key. Blends of cotton and polyester, such as cotton-fleece blends or performance knits,
If your goal is to choose the best fabric for aprons, the decision cannot be based on appearance alone. In workwear, materials are exposed
TLDR: The best uniform fabrics combine durability, comfort, professional appearance, and easy care. For most uses, polyester-cotton blends, performance polyesters, and weaves like twill